blog purpose

blog purpose

Friday 11 March 2016

Underground Pearl Prosper evaluation


The work of Prosper, a programme commissioned by Canterbury Festival and funded by the Arts Council of England which was designed to encourage cultural and social development through the arts in East Kent in South East England. The report focuses in particular on the second and final ‘Adventure’ phase of 5 multi-agency initiatives: Underground Pearl, Singing Windows, Moving Well, The Student Makers Market and White Horses Whitstable.
The programme was designed and delivered by The Map Consortium alongside Workers of Art, a community interest company based in East Kent, working in partnership with commissioning agency, Canterbury Festival. Shakespeare’s The Tempest was a significant point of reference and inspiration for the programme’s steering partners, reflecting their histories of working with the arts on events and programmes of social change the work of Prosper, a programme commissioned by Canterbury Festival and funded by the Arts Council of England which was designed to encourage cultural and social development through the arts in East Kent in South East England. The report focuses in particular on the second and final ‘Adventure’ phase of 5 multi-agency initiatives: Underground Pearl, Singing Windows, Moving Well, The Student Makers Market and White Horses Whitstable.
The programme was designed and delivered by The Map Consortium alongside Workers of Art, a community interest company based in East Kent, working in partnership with commissioning agency, Canterbury Festival. Shakespeare’s The Tempest was a significant point of reference and inspiration for the programme’s steering partners, reflecting their histories of working with the arts on events and programmes of social change.

In the first ‘Experiment’ phase of the programme (September 2012 to March 2013) 13 partnerships involving at least one artist or arts organisation were awarded small grants of up to £5,000 to research, plan and carry out a practical experiment that explored unlikely connections in 3 areas of enquiry:

Social Change – how collaboration might make a difference to ways in which communities are shaped and potentially transformed
Place – how collaboration can shift or encourage different understandings, or connections to a place
Interdisciplinary Work – how collaboration between artists from different disciplines can develop new skills and thinking working with professionals from other sectors.

1. An initial locally-focused and personally-bridged recruitment effort led by the Prosper Team: the Map Consortium and Workers of Art.
2. The creation of a network of collaborators.
3. A carefully calibrated set of conditions and criteria for participation to establish diverse collaborations and encourage experiment, risk, ownership and sustainability.
4. A programme of Creative Labs to support the development of practice and the cross-fertilisation of ideas and opportunities.
5. Support through individual contact with The Map Consortium and Workers of Art and mentoring from professionals with expert knowledge relevant to each Adventure.
6. Support from the Canterbury Festival, as a key regional strategic organisation providing advice on further development and profiling Prosper work through 2013 Festival events
2


An initial experiment was led by Katryn Saqui, an artist based in Deal, and a local fisherman, Nigel Clements. It explored ways of collaborating with Deal’s dwindling fishing fleet and making connections between the community, fishermen and the town’s artists. The partnership worked with the enquiry questions:
Are these the last fishermen?
Can artists have a presence in a town with no contemporary gallery?
The questions were used to shape conversations in events titled ‘in and out of place’, that explored polarities between the diminishing fishing industry and the artists of Deal to explore ideas of belonging. Adventure funding allowed partners to continue to challenge separations and disconnectedness in their community.

‘Cast from the solitude of our studios and fishing boats, we are lured to the beach. Our paint brushes, canvases and nets have been tossed to the economic storm and swept under the rocks. The gift of the ebb tide was the discovery of the poetics of our coastline, Prosper, Canterbury Festival and the UCA MA Fine Art. They have reeled us out of metaphorical sinking sand and into a fresh changing tide that turned in February 2013. It shifted our artistic direction, materials and solitude to a new and unfamiliar ‘CURRENSEA’ (meaning: new perspectives, roaring opportunities, continual stream of collaborations, a gentle flow of friendships and oceanic inspiration to equip us to keep moving forward and negotiate future storms). This is one way contemporary artists can survive in a town with no contemporary gallery space. We are in constant flux with projects and fluid with creativity and curiosity. In this way Underground Pearl is connected to the tides of its mystical coastal past and is shaping a new contemporary horizon’.
Kate Saqui.

Adventure Partners
In the Adventure phase, artist Kati Saqui continued her collaboration with new partner artist Loren Beven with the initial goal of creating a fish ‘stall’ that would develop the partners’ previous curated conversations with a broader net of partners to explore ideas of sustainability and change. The Adventure, though smaller in scale than others, expanded in ambition as it attracted new partners and has had far-reaching impacts, particularly in relation to a legacy of new commissions for the original Adventure Partners. Many additional local partners were involved in contributing to events, including an art salon and beach cinema. Partners did not employ an additional evaluator but experimented instead with a range of creative evaluation tools. This Adventure also illustrates how an inspirational idea for an artistic intervention can lead to a new model of consultation and relationship between a local council and its community.

Adventure partnership collaborators: Dr. Terry Perk UCA, Art Salon leader, Martine Brown, actor, Tom Rowland, journalist, local historian and boat owner, Barbara Salter, donor of screen (in-kind gift), Colin Priest, Architect from Chelsea Arts School, Danny Burrows, photographer, Matthew Sharp, Artistic Director, Deal Music Festival, Peter Stange, loan of Orkney Spinner boat for cinema, Andy Burrows, local fisherman and historian, Carolle Ford, Sea Café chef, Rachel Wolf, artist who documented events, Nigel Clements, fisherman and Michael Tyburski, film director. Clare Smith and Joanna Jones of Dover Arts Development, Wendy Daws, artist, Päivi Seppälä of LV21, Kent Autistic Trust, Deal Parochial School, Castle Community College, 20 schools in Medway on the INSPRE programme, Strange Cargo, UCA art foundation student, Wendy Bagley, Greenpeace.

Activities
Adventure discussions focused on the potential of the locality and the beach, in particular, to act as a centre for community engagement. Activities included:

A Beach cinema. In September 2013, a Cine Boat event was created through an interactive sculpture that created awareness of Deal’s shrimping heritage. Further research was carried out through the use of jars and a series of encounters to ask questions about art in the area and future possibilities. A two seat Cine Boat, an Orkney Spinner, generated further interest in the possibilities of the sea with a screening of the film Angel Fish , directed by Michael Tyburski, about the overview effect which sailors get at sea, experiencing euphoria prompted by seemingly limitless horizons.
Underground Pearl’s art intervention ‘Rise of the Renegade’ used 2000 glow sticks to magically illuminated Deal Festival’s staging of ‘Britten on the Beach’, a storytelling and musical event taking place in and around beach huts and boats at Walmer. This intervention commemorated the event in 1814 when William Pitt the Younger ordered the burning of the boats on Walmer beach to suppress the smuggling trade.
Art Salon. Underground Pearl hosted its first art salon in June 2013 in a boat on Walmer beach. Led by Dr. Terry Perk, course leader, M.A. Fine Art at the University for the Creative Arts at Canterbury, the salon generated new perspectives of enquiry through an exploration of the poetics of the boat in relation to technology, geography and site.

Additional Partnerships. As an extra event, the Adventure partners, Katie Saqui and Loren visited the École Supérieure d’Art et Dessin for a talk on Underground Pearl for 124 students. The opportunity arose through the artists’ MA studies at the University for the Creative Arts, Canterbury. The visit led to opportunities to connect with other local artists and has also led to further exchange visits between the universities with potential for further collaboration and exchange.

As artists, the Adventure partners experimented with different means to gather data creatively as an ‘illustrated mapping’. The cine-boat was conceived of as a cultural laboratory which involved both cinema and conversation and ways to record visitors’ views and responses to questions. They used, for example, jars with titles on them. People could place pebbles in them to indicate what they would like to see happening in Deal. These creative consultation tools provided information that shaped planning for interventions. Data gathered was used also as part of a formative assessment process as to the impacts of activities but the methods chosen precluded wider analysis of long-term social benefits.

Underground Pearl’s vision of collaboration is strongly rooted in their artistic practice and ways in which this facilitates new connections between place and community. Situating artwork and events on the beach was identified by the Adventure Partners as a significant contributor to increasing interest and engagement from the local community.

Adventure Partners also see huge potential in the way the council has responded imaginatively to the artists’ work as a means to bridge the gap between the council and the wider community: ‘they like our nutty ideas’.
‘Connecting history and contemporary art through casting a light on it... we’re illuminating the two, merging the two with light...’
‘The realisation of the power of collaboration has been very significant, working on the beach creates lots of curiosity and interest, people want to get involved when they find out what we are doing – bridging the gap between council and community, this is what working on the beach gives us’.
‘We felt the need to play with light as a signature...The Burning of the Boats had massive strength in winning commissions. We never envisaged that....’
DAD lantern procession images.


Building Cultural Capacity Conversations, Commissions and Legacy.
‘we’ve had small audiences but it has had a massive impact in other ways... It will be a slow growing thing... we had to build that up.... ‘we’re used to working in our studios and going to suddenly doing something we can’t possibly do on our own. That’s an adjustment...’ Katryn Saqui
Image of DPS

The trajectory of the Adventure has demonstrated how low-key interventions create opportunities for conversation, exchange of ideas and raising awareness. The situation of events on the beach provided a point of connection between the community, its location and its history encouraging new perspectives on how these connections could be revived. These processes were also shaped by the innovation of the event delivery. The prominence and boldness of the Burning Boats event, for example, was a key catalyst in generating interest in Underground Pearl which led directly to further commissions, including:
Dover Arts Development. As part of their Nautical Threads project, Underground Pearl has illuminated a street procession, co-ordinated the event and run school workshops about the project.
Walmer Council has also commissioned 2 projects:
i. An Environmental Consultation week, ‘surveying litter as a social art project’ to encourage different ways of dealing with litter
ii. Installations accompanied by workshops designed to prepare young people to engage in ways of preparing funding applications.
LV21. Working with the new Gillingham-based arts organisation based on a former lightship, Underground Pearl are running 5 mini-residency days, working with Kent Autistic Trust and local artist Wendy Dawes
Other enquiries are in progress with the North Kent Sports Programme and with the Trinity House Goodwin Sands project and the Cheriton Trust
The company is also applying for an ACE development grant.

Building Cultural Capacity. Exponential growth in attracting additional partners and commissions. The increased scale of interventions has continued to be led by a key driver identified in our Interim report: the role of bold, innovative arts practice in ‘disrupting’ social spaces to provoke community reaction and engagement. The novelty and ‘otherness’ of the artists’ installation and activity have acted as catalysts to seed new conversations and relationships with councils and other agencies, leading to gains in commissions for participating arts organisations.
Site-specific work at the heart of Adventure interventions. Creating audience encounters on the beach, as a new site of social interaction, has been a notable successful element of 2 Adventures. The Singing Windows Adventure has also demonstrated the capacity.

Interdisciplinary work and collaboration as an instrument of social change. Cross-disciplinary experiment has remained central to Adventure Activity. The increasing role of local councils and universities in the Adventures has generated strong future development routes to explore the potential and challenges for arts-led social change and collaboration
Collaboration. Reflection on the ‘how’ of constructing cross-disciplinary Adventures has been a central theme of the Labs that have accompanied the Adventures (facilitated by The MAP Consortium with Workers of Art). This summary of the final Lab discussion focuses, as a conclusion on this key area, on the discoveries of collaborative practice that Adventure partners identified as important to pass on into future practice and others engaged in this work.

Summary of Prosper Final Lab Reflections
It’s shown the importance of playfulness as a social tool, as an important ingredient to engage new audiences in conversation and the need to...
Being around people you wouldn’t normally be around.
Moving from always ‘doing’ to teaching and sharing with others.
Creating opportunity to work across different backgrounds and practices.
Income generation – moving from being unemployed to self employed.
‘Through collaborative arts, we have found the potential to bring revenue streams in’.
Place – conserving traditional skills, language, values by showing them in new ways.
As a fundamental aspect of collaborative work between widely-varying partners, the concept of experimentation was identified as a vital component in building a shared ethos:
Shifting preconceptions
The concept of ‘Experiment freeing us from expectations’
the value of putting equal merit on different perspectives on activity, ‘you can collaborate and still be independent’
Creating a centre of gravity that others got pulled into
Building a sense of the collective
Endurance – having to get something tangible in front of people before they understand enough to step in
Being asked to reflect brought rigour, it could have just been free play... academics also brought rigour and a helpful tension.
Staying open to communicating outward, allowing people to come into the process, avoiding preciousness
‘There have been pleasant surprises, generosity, people coming forward.

‘It’s important for artists to focus both on relationships as much as process and also on the small steps that allow things to evolve in ways other than ‘end-gaming grand schemes’. MAP Consortium.

The legacy of Prosper is:
‘A new sense of aesthetic and process around arts and ‘change’ work and the border lines between public art and participative art’
A new approach to ‘growing cultural capacity’ - an understanding of a process that can deliver it in lasting ways
New practice / approach to thinking and processes for artists, institutions, organisations and communities